How we score
1. Hard filters come first
A substitute must be within ±10% of the original’s metres per 100 g. We never match on labels like “DK”: they cover too wide a range.
It must be sold by a shop that ships to your country (turn off “Near me” to see everything), and pass your values and allergy filters.
Filters are strict: a yarn with unknown fibre content never passes a fibre filter such as wool-free.
2. Then a weighted score
Each factor scores 0–100. Your sliders set how much each one counts; we normalise them to 100%. The defaults:
- Gauge fit: 30%
- Fibre: 20%
- Drape: 15%
- Look: 15%
- Washability: 10%
- Price: 10%
Gauge fit uses community swatches once a yarn has 5 or more; until then it uses the label gauge, and the evidence panel says so. Price uses the cheapest delivered total for your whole project.
3. Warnings and risk
Behaviour warnings come from one rule table: superwash grows, cotton and linen ribbing sags, alpaca stretches, and more. Risk is low, medium or high, from the thickness gap, any change of fibre class, and the number of warnings.
4. Money
Delivered total = skeins × unit price + shipping + a VAT/customs estimate, converted to your currency. Prices are checked daily; anything older than 24 hours shows as “possibly outdated”.
Ranking is never bought. Featured shops pay to be labelled, and we may earn a commission when you buy. Neither changes any score or the order.